918-351-PIES Order Now
Wed-Sat · 9 AM to 6 PM (or until sold out)
Hand-folded Oklahoma fried pies at the Fulton Fried Pies counter in Muskogee
715 North York St • Muskogee

Experience the
Fulton Difference.

Multi-generation Oklahoma fried pies: hand-folded, fried fresh, and served warm at our window on North York St. Peach and cherry lead the case; breakfast pies too. Wednesday through Saturday, 9 AM to 6 PM, or until we're sold out that day.

Start an Order Vote on Flavors

Same Recipe, New Chapter in Muskogee

Our story begins in the Oklahoma hills in the 1800s, where the family dough tradition that still guides our kitchen took shape. Byron's great-great-grandmother carried it forward, hand to hand, generation to generation. In 1994 the first Fulton fried pie shop opened in Ardmore with family pulling together at the table, and in the decades since we've baked our way across Oklahoma. Muskogee is where we've put down roots now. We're building again under the original Fulton name, with the same patience and care in every fold.

We chase the best ingredients we can put in a pie: premium cocoa, coconut, vanilla, and flour we actually test. Not a "local for local's sake" pitch: just honest food built the way we'd serve our own table.

We're grateful to serve neighbors from every walk of life. Our faith shapes how we treat people at the window, with patience and respect.

Open Wed-Sat · 9 AM to 6 PM (or until sold out)
100% Hand-Folded
Fresh Fried Daily
100% Hand-Folded
Wed-Sat 9 AM to 6 PM · Or sold out
$4.75 Fruit & cream pies
5.0 stars · 9 Google reviews

Muskogee is already talking.

Real Google reviews for Fulton Fried Pies & Bakery at 715 North York St: fresh pies, friendly service, and crust worth waiting for.

Google ★★★★★
“Hot, freshly made, and great taste. The texture is crisp, not soggy. The filling is full, not half-empty.”
Jamison Faught Google review
Google ★★★★★
“Amazing homemade pies. My family loves them.”
H Dunlap Google review
Google ★★★★★
“The coconut fried pie is wonderful, so was the cherry. He cooks them to order. It is worth it.”
Charles Evans Google review
Google ★★★★★
“Man behind the counter was wonderful, made my order fresh, and I didn't mind waiting for hot pies.”
Rachel Bowman Google review
Google ★★★★★
“Christian business good pies.”
Vicki Pigg Google review
Google ★★★★★
“If you've ever had the Arbuckle Fried Pies in Davis, OK, these are every bit as good, if not better!”
Jamison Faught Google review
Hand-folded pie dough on a floured surface
Our Story

Why Fulton Tastes Different

Fulton Fried Pies & Bakery is a family-run shop: JC and his son Byron at the fryer and the window. Every pie is hand-folded from a proprietary family dough, filled with ingredients we don't compromise on, and fried until the crust is crisp and golden.

It's a family recipe; the standard is the same every day. We're still cooking like that: no frozen shortcuts, no pretending we're something we're not. Pull through Wednesday through Saturday, 9 AM to 6 PM, or call ahead if you're chasing something specific. When we're sold out, we're sold out. That's the trade-off for doing it fresh.

Eat with confidence

Allergens, Sugar-Free Options & Custom Orders

Sugar-Free Options

Lower-sugar sugar-free fillings are available for every fruit fried pie when you pre-order. What's in the case varies day to day, so call ahead and we'll set yours aside, or ask at the window. Talk to your doctor about whether it fits your diet; we don't make medical claims.

Allergens

All pies are made in a shared kitchen with wheat, dairy, and eggs. Tree nuts and peanuts are not in our standard pies, but cross-contact is possible. Ask before ordering if you have a serious allergy.

Custom Orders

Birthdays, office boxes, holidays, weddings: call ahead and we'll plan it. 24-hour notice is plenty for most custom flavors and bulk orders.

Full FAQ

Hours, payment, delivery zones, lower-sugar builds, gluten, hiring: the full list of questions answered in detail.

Read the FAQ →
Monthly Flavor Vote

Pick the Next Drop

Three picks, one per category (fruit, cream, and savory). Every month we tally the votes and the winning fruit, cream, and savory each get a weekend run in the case before the slate rotates.

One ballot per device. Results below are live across every visitor.

Live Leaders

Fruit Pick your favorite fruit pie
Cream Pick your favorite cream pie
Savory Pick your favorite savory pie

Free Pie · Pie Club

Free pie on your
birthday.

Join the Pie Club and we'll send you a coupon for a free pie during your birthday week, plus first-look texts when a limited flavor drops. No spam, no daily emails; about one message a month.

  • · Free fried pie coupon during your birthday week
  • · First-look on limited drops & weekend specials
  • · Early access on holiday and Thanksgiving boxes
Simple signup

Save your spot.

Drop your name, email, and birthday month/day. We'll add you to the birthday coupon list and keep flavor-drop messages light.

Birthday coupons are sent during your birthday week. No daily emails.

Get in touch

Bulk, catering, or just a question?

Office boxes, weddings, holiday orders, partner inquiries: drop a note and we'll reply within one business day. For same-day requests, please call. Custom flavors appreciate 24+ hours of notice.

Fastest way to reach us

Send us the details.

For office boxes, catering, custom flavors, or general questions, email is the cleanest way to start. We'll reply as soon as we're away from the fryer.

Email Us Call Instead

Same-day questions are best by phone. Bigger orders are easier by email.

Visit the Bakery

On North York St in Muskogee: pull through or walk up. Arrive early for the best selection; when the case is empty, we've fried everything we're making that day.

Our Address

715 North York St

Muskogee, OK 74403

Bakery Hours

8:00 AM to 7:00 PM (or until sold out)

Wednesday thru Saturday

GET DIRECTIONS
Wed-Sat · 9 AM to 6 PM (or until sold out)
Call Go Pickup DoorDash

Made with ❤️ by Gnomad Studio 🦙